Two white ceramic dishes of thick plain yogurt on a pink cloth and wooden table
|

Best Goat and Sheep Milk Kefir and Yogurt Brands (2026): Gundry-Friendly A2 Dairy

Affiliate disclosure: My Lectin Free Lunchbox may earn a commission from qualifying purchases, including as an Amazon Associate, at no extra cost to you.

This article is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice. If you have a milk allergy, are lactose intolerant, are pregnant, are immunocompromised or have a digestive condition, talk with your clinician before adding new dairy or fermented foods.

Regular yogurt and kefir are on the “no” side of Dr. Steven Gundry’s plan. The reason is not lectins. It is a protein called A1 beta-casein, found in milk from most North American dairy cows, which Gundry believes can irritate the gut. His Energy Paradox Yes/No list puts kefir and yogurt made from conventional cow’s milk on the No list, and puts plain goat’s milk yogurt, plain sheep’s milk yogurt, and plain goat’s and sheep’s milk kefir on the Yes list, along with A2 casein milk. Goats and sheep naturally make A2-type casein.

The catch is finding them. Goat and sheep dairy is a small corner of most grocery stores, and the brands change from region to region. Below are the goat and sheep kefir and yogurt brands we found on Amazon, plus an A2 cow’s milk yogurt and two do-it-yourself options for when you cannot find them locally.

How we picked: every product was listed and available to add to the cart on Amazon when we checked on November 20, 2026, and ingredients come from the live listings. The refrigerated items are sold by Whole Foods Market through Amazon, so availability depends on your delivery ZIP code. We favored plain, unsweetened products with short ingredient lists. We have not taste-tested these specific products, and labels change, so check the package you receive.

Two white ceramic dishes of thick plain yogurt on a pink cloth and wooden table
Photo by elif tekkaya on Pexels

Quick picks: best goat and sheep milk kefir and yogurt

ProductMilkBest forLink
Meyenberg Plain Goat KefirGoatBest goat kefirCheck price on Amazon
Meyenberg Plain Goat YogurtGoatEasiest goat yogurt to findCheck price on Amazon
Bellwether Farms Plain Sheep Milk YogurtSheepBest sheep yogurt (simplest ingredients)Check price on Amazon
Old Chatham Plain Sheep Milk YogurtSheepSingle-serve cupsCheck price on Amazon
Alexandre Family Farm Organic Plain A2 YogurtA2 cowMilder taste, A2 cow’s milkCheck price on Amazon
Cultures for Health Kefir StarterDIY cultureMake your own goat kefirCheck price on Amazon
Mt. Capra Whole Goat Milk PowderGoat (powder)Shelf-stable base for DIYCheck price on Amazon

Why goat and sheep dairy fit a Gundry-style diet

  • A2 instead of A1 casein. Goat and sheep milk contain A2-type beta-casein. Gundry argues that A1 casein from most modern cows can be inflammatory. Research on this is still limited. One small 2016 trial in Nutrition Journal found fewer digestive symptoms when participants drank A2-only cow’s milk than when they drank conventional milk, but it was small and more research is needed.
  • Fermentation. Kefir is fermented with a mix of bacteria and yeasts. A 2017 review in Nutrition Research Reviews summarized research on milk kefir, including possible benefits for digestion and lactose tolerance, while noting that more human trials are needed.
  • Portion limits still apply. Gundry’s list limits dairy to about 4 ounces of yogurt or 1 ounce of cheese per day. A goat yogurt is a condiment or a small snack, not a big bowl.
  • Plain only. Flavored yogurts and kefirs usually add sugar. Buy plain and sweeten at home with a little allulose, monk fruit or berries.

Watch: Dr. Gundry on the healthiest yogurts

In this episode of The Dr. Gundry Podcast, Dr. Gundry explains why many mainstream yogurts are closer to dessert than health food, and which kinds of yogurt he says yes to.

The 3 Healthiest Yogurts You Need to Start Eating, from The Dr. Gundry Podcast

Goat milk kefir and yogurt

1. Meyenberg Plain Goat Kefir: best goat kefir

Meyenberg is a long-running U.S. goat dairy brand, and its plain goat kefir is the easiest goat or sheep kefir we found on Amazon. The ingredient list is short: pasteurized whole goat milk and live and active cultures. Meyenberg lists 11 bacterial strains, including several Lactobacillus species, Bifidobacterium lactis and Lactococcus strains.

It comes in a 32-ounce bottle with a listed shelf life of about 14 days. Expect a tangy, slightly goaty flavor that is milder in a smoothie with berries or a few drops of monk fruit. Goat kefir also showed up in our fermented foods guide because it is the simplest way to get kefir on a Gundry-style plan.

What’s in it

  • Ingredients: pasteurized whole goat milk, live and active cultures
  • Cultures: 11 listed strains, including B. lactis, L. acidophilus, L. casei and L. rhamnosus
  • Size: 32 fl oz
  • Sweetened: no (plain)
  • Sold by: Whole Foods Market on Amazon

Pros

  • Goat’s milk kefir is on Gundry’s Yes list
  • Short ingredient list, no added sugar
  • Wide variety of cultures

Cons

  • Tangy, goaty taste takes getting used to
  • Refrigerated delivery depends on your area
  • Short shelf life once opened

Best for: Anyone who wants a ready-to-drink A2 kefir without making it at home.

2. Meyenberg Plain Goat Yogurt: easiest goat yogurt to find

Meyenberg’s plain goat yogurt comes in a 32-ounce tub and uses pasteurized whole goat milk with seven live cultures, including Bifidobacterium lactis, L. acidophilus, L. casei and L. rhamnosus. It also contains modified tapioca starch and pectin, which give goat yogurt (naturally thinner than cow yogurt) a spoonable texture.

Tapioca comes from cassava, which is on Gundry’s Yes list, so it does not break the plan, but if you prefer yogurt with only milk and cultures, the sheep yogurts below are simpler.

What’s in it

  • Ingredients: pasteurized whole goat milk, modified tapioca starch, pectin, live and active cultures
  • Cultures: 7 listed strains
  • Size: 32 oz tub
  • Sweetened: no (plain)
  • Sold by: Whole Foods Market on Amazon

Pros

  • Plain goat yogurt is on Gundry’s Yes list
  • Large tub for the price of entry
  • Includes probiotic strains like L. rhamnosus and B. lactis

Cons

  • Added starch and pectin thickeners
  • Milder but still noticeably goaty flavor

Best for: Everyday use in dressings, dips and small breakfast servings.

Sheep milk yogurt

3. Bellwether Farms Plain Sheep Milk Yogurt: best sheep yogurt

Sheep milk is naturally richer than goat or cow milk, which makes sheep yogurt thick and creamy without thickeners. Bellwether Farms, a California creamery, keeps the ingredient list to pasteurized sheep milk plus cultures (S. thermophilus, L. bulgaricus, L. acidophilus and Bifidus). It is kosher certified.

Many people who cannot get used to goat dairy find sheep yogurt milder. The 24-ounce tub is a good size for a household that eats a few ounces a day.

What’s in it

  • Ingredients: pasteurized sheep milk, live cultures
  • Cultures: S. thermophilus, L. bulgaricus, L. acidophilus, Bifidus
  • Size: 24 oz tub
  • Certification: kosher
  • Sold by: Whole Foods Market on Amazon

Pros

  • Only milk and cultures; no thickeners
  • Rich, creamy texture
  • Usually milder than goat yogurt

Cons

  • Harder to find in stores than goat yogurt
  • Refrigerated delivery depends on your area

Best for: Readers who want the cleanest label and a creamy, mild yogurt.

4. Old Chatham Plain Sheep Milk Yogurt: best single-serve cups

Old Chatham, a New York sheep dairy, sells its plain sheep milk yogurt in 5.3-ounce cups. The ingredients are pasteurized sheep milk and six live cultures, including Bifidobacterium, L. acidophilus, L. paracasei and L. rhamnosus.

A single cup is close to Gundry’s 4-ounce daily yogurt limit, which makes these handy for lunchboxes and portion control.

What’s in it

  • Ingredients: pasteurized sheep milk, live and active cultures
  • Cultures: 6 listed strains
  • Size: 5.3 oz cup
  • Sweetened: no (plain)
  • Sold by: Whole Foods Market on Amazon

Pros

  • Simple ingredients
  • Built-in portion control
  • Easy to pack in a lunchbox

Cons

  • Costs more per ounce than a tub
  • Sold one cup at a time

Best for: Lunchboxes and anyone trying to stick to a 4-ounce serving.

Swing-top glass bottle of milk against a light blue background
Photo by Zakhar Vozhdaienko on Pexels

A2 cow’s milk alternative

5. Alexandre Family Farm Organic Plain A2 Whole Milk Yogurt: best A2 cow’s milk option

If goat and sheep yogurt are too strong for you, A2 cow’s milk is the compromise. Gundry’s list includes A2 casein milk, and Alexandre Family Farm in Northern California is known for certified A2/A2 herds. This plain yogurt is made with organic, 100% grass-fed milk and live cultures, including L. rhamnosus, Bifidobacterium species, L. acidophilus, L. paracasei, L. bulgaricus and S. thermophilus.

Note that the Yes list specifically names A2 casein milk, so this is a judgment call for strict followers. It is the mildest-tasting option in this guide.

What’s in it

  • Ingredients: organic 100% grass-fed milk (A2), live and active cultures
  • Size: 24 oz
  • Certification: organic, kosher
  • Sold by: Whole Foods Market on Amazon

Pros

  • Familiar cow’s milk flavor
  • Organic and grass-fed
  • Good bridge for kids and skeptical family members

Cons

  • Not goat or sheep milk
  • Strict Gundry followers may stick to goat and sheep

Best for: Families easing off regular yogurt who find goat dairy too strong.

Make your own goat kefir or yogurt

If you cannot get refrigerated goat or sheep dairy delivered, making your own is easy and cheap. You need a culture and a goat milk base. For yogurt, our guide to yogurt makers for goat milk yogurt covers the Instant Pot and other machines that hold a steady temperature.

6. Cultures for Health Kefir Starter Culture: easiest way to make goat kefir

Kefir grains are the traditional way to make kefir, but they need daily feeding. This freeze-dried powdered starter from Cultures for Health is simpler: you get 4 packets, and each can be re-cultured 2 to 7 times by saving about a quarter cup from the last batch. The maker says each batch is pathogen tested by a third-party lab.

It works with goat milk, and the maker also lists coconut milk, water and juice as options, so you can make a dairy-free kefir too. Culture it at room temperature and it is usually ready in less than a day.

What’s in it

  • Contents: 4 packets of freeze-dried kefir starter
  • Re-culturing: 2 to 7 times per packet (per the listing)
  • Works with: milk (including goat), coconut milk, water or juice
  • Testing: third-party pathogen tested

Pros

  • No grains to keep alive
  • Works with goat milk or coconut milk
  • Low cost per quart

Cons

  • Fewer strains than live kefir grains
  • Eventually needs a new packet

Best for: Beginners who want homemade goat or coconut kefir without maintaining grains.

7. Mt. Capra Whole Goat Milk Powder: best shelf-stable goat milk base

Fresh goat milk is not sold everywhere, and refrigerated delivery is spotty. Mt. Capra’s whole goat milk powder comes from small family-owned Dutch farms with grass-fed goats, contains only goat milk (no added vitamins or fillers), and has a listed shelf life of about a year. Mix 2 scoops into 8 ounces of warm water for a cup of milk.

Reconstituted goat milk can be fermented with a kefir starter or yogurt culture. Results with powdered milk can be a bit thinner than fresh, so some people add a little extra powder for body. If you can get it, Meyenberg also sells a whole goat milk quart on Amazon that works as a fresh base.

What’s in it

  • Ingredients: 100% whole goat milk powder
  • Size: 1 lb (16 servings)
  • Source: grass-fed goats, Dutch family farms
  • Shelf life: about 365 days (per the listing)

Pros

  • Shelf-stable; no cold shipping needed
  • Single ingredient
  • Handy for travel and baking too

Cons

  • Pricier per cup than fresh milk
  • Homemade results take some trial and error

Best for: Anyone who cannot find fresh goat milk locally and wants to make kefir or yogurt at home.

Watch: how to make goat milk kefir

The Farmhouse Mom shows the whole process of making goat milk kefir at home with live kefir grains. If you use a powdered starter instead, follow the packet directions, but the basics of straining and storing are the same.

How to Make Goat Milk Kefir, from The Farmhouse Mom

Buyer’s guide: choosing goat and sheep dairy

Always buy plain

Flavored kefir and yogurt can have as much added sugar as dessert. Plain products let you control sweetness with berries, a few drops of monk fruit or a little allulose.

Read the ingredient list

The best products list only milk and cultures. Thickeners like tapioca starch and pectin are not lectin problems, but they are worth knowing about. Avoid products with added cornstarch, sugar or “milk protein concentrate” from cow’s milk.

Look for live and active cultures

More strains is not automatically better, but a label that names specific live cultures tells you the product was actually fermented and not just acidified.

Mind the portion

Gundry suggests limiting yogurt to about 4 ounces a day. Use goat or sheep yogurt as a topping, in a dressing or as a small snack.

Check delivery and storage

Refrigerated dairy on Amazon ships through Whole Foods Market or Amazon Fresh in many areas but not everywhere. If it does not deliver to you, check your local Whole Foods, Sprouts or co-op, or make your own with a starter and goat milk.

Goat and sheep kefir FAQ

Is goat milk kefir lectin-free?

Milk is not a significant source of lectins. Gundry’s concern with dairy is A1 beta-casein, not lectins. Plain goat’s and sheep’s milk kefir are on his Yes list.

Is goat kefir easier to digest than cow kefir?

Many people say so, and fermentation breaks down much of the lactose. But goat milk still contains lactose and casein. If you have a diagnosed milk allergy, goat and sheep milk are not safe substitutes; talk with your allergist.

What does sheep milk yogurt taste like?

Sheep yogurt is usually creamier and milder than goat yogurt, with a rich, slightly sweet tang. People who dislike the “goaty” flavor often prefer sheep.

Can I use goat yogurt in cooking?

Yes. It works in dressings, marinades, dips and sauces. Add it at the end of cooking or off the heat, because high heat can make it separate.

Is A2 cow yogurt the same as goat yogurt?

No. Both avoid A1 beta-casein, but A2 cow yogurt comes from cows bred to produce only A2 casein. Gundry’s list names A2 casein milk, while goat and sheep yogurt and kefir are listed directly.

Did you taste-test these products?

No. We have not tried the specific products in this guide. Our picks are based on their listed ingredients and how well they fit a Gundry-style plan.

Bottom line

For a ready-to-drink option, Meyenberg’s plain goat kefir is the easiest A2 kefir to buy online. For yogurt, Bellwether Farms’ sheep milk yogurt has the cleanest label, Old Chatham’s cups make portion control easy, and Meyenberg’s goat yogurt is the most widely available. If goat and sheep are too strong for your family, Alexandre’s A2 yogurt is a gentler step. And if refrigerated delivery does not reach you, a Cultures for Health kefir starter plus Mt. Capra goat milk powder lets you make your own. Keep it plain, keep portions small and enjoy it as part of an overall lectin-light diet.

Similar Posts